I like historical mysteries. Sometimes the lead me on a merry chase. Such is the case with the cave associated with the Bloomer Brewery. My first two posts on this are worth a read to get context. Oh, TLDR? Well here's the basic dates and data. BLOOMER PART I. and BLOOMER PART II.
1872 brewery established. Presumably a lagering cave was created at that time.
1880's two fires damage or perhaps destroy the original brewery. First of several rebuilds and additions begin.
1934 - We have a nice architectural drawing of the place. New data!
1964 - a survey by the Department of Defense is taken of underground spaces in America. Places where citizens might ride out a nuclear apocalpyse. The caves of the Bloomer Brewery were rated for over 500 people!mid 1970's. My friends at the bar start working at the place.
Just recently the cave area was showcased with nice new woodwork and framing. I wish more caves were given this respect.
About those new friends. I'd made arrangements to revisit the site after new owners bashed a hole in the wall exposing a cave I'd suspected was there but now, yes NOW I would get all the answers. One of the folks I had lunch with had actually fallen into a hole out back of the building, tipping them off to an underground space! That's what prompted them to have at the back wall of the known - but rather tiny - caves for a look see. The hole is visible in the above photo. Let's take a peek.
First, here's a look at the back wall today.
A ladder was helpfully obtained. Looking at the newly created hole we can see that it went through some newer, definitely 20th century, materials that had been plastered over. I'm thinking 1920s.
And what lies beyond?
Huh. There's only about another 15 feet of cave back there. With of course a vent hole that is just the right size to put a leg down into. Glad nobody got hurt. I see no plausible side passages. The black material might be tar adhesive for cork, but given the state of disrepair is more likely nasty fungus stuff.
So how to put this all together?
Please consider this nothing more than educated speculation. But I have had a chance to examine the brewery caves of enterprises large and small, old and new, successful and....otherwise.
I think what we are seeing here is the original 1870's lagering cave. It's not big, but just maybe big enough. The brewery put up around 500 barrels of beer in 1875, and if we assume it was not all in one batch you could almost manage it with this space. Or a bit more, but we'll get to that part. There have always been features of this cave that did not make sense. For instance the rather formidable "ante chamber". For a simple cave that lead into the nice convenient space of the brewery basement this engineering is rather over the top.
I wonder if this was actually a cave adjacent to the original brewery? Fires in 1882 and 1883 did a lot of damage. After the second fire the brewery was rebuilt on a larger scale. Honestly this complex of buildings and additions is quite the architectural mess.
Let's tidy things up a bit. Here's what the brewery looked like in 1915.
The cave we've been looking at is, of course, straight back from those big double doors. The massive barn like structure on the left is certainly the 1880's rebuild. Or part of it. Now, in 1934 there was a detailed architectural study made of the structure.
You can see the big wing off to the left. That's the 1880's "barn" area. Now full of ageing vats. They would have had mechanical refrigeration by then. You can also see up at the top, the little extension that is the two chambers of the "caves". You do NOT see the space beyond the wall, so that was sealed off by the 1930's. You also do not see any other caves coming off what looks like solid back walls. But if they ignored one sealed off archway it is reasonable to assume they could ignore others.
The area to consider carefully is in that 1880's addition. It was not open for a look on this visit, but last time I was there here's the back wall of it.
Drywall. Or maybe just mostly dry. This was installed during the memory of my friends up at the bar. They spoke admiringly of the massive construction of the wall hidden behind it. And told me that water seeping through was a big enough issue that they had to install drain pipes back there to divert it. Oh, and it seemed to be particularly bad around some odd places that looked like sealed off doorways.....
Until some day when the moisture finally wins and the drywall is replaced, I'll just keep assuming that there are additional storage caves back there. The output of the brewery in the 1880's was presumably more than the original cave could handle, and I deem it unlikely that they'd have gone early for the mechanical refrigeration. It was not a successful enough operation to be an early adopter of expensive new technology.
That leaves one additional mystery. How would you fit 500 plus nuclear refugees into this place? Per the 1934 drawing there was no way they could have shown whoever came around for a look any caves that would come close. So it must have been the basement space in my last photo. And while this is cheating a bit I want to be fair. The ceiling of this was supporting huge brew kettles and other heavy things. It is supported by beams and girders, and has a ridiculous composition of thick layers of wood and three or four inches of honest to goodness concrete. It would be a plausible fallout shelter despite having its front section be above ground. A number of civil defense signs found in this area would seem to back this theory up.
Maybe when the inspector came around in the early 1960's he looked at the actual cave, shook his head sadly....and then got into a friendly discussion with the locals over a couple of beers. "Ah, heck. Close enough for Government work!"
I would be remiss if I did not mention that the Old Bloomer Brewery Bar and Grill served up a great burger and fries, and although I was - due to other commitments - not able to enjoy a beer or two, that should not stop any of you from doing so!









.jpg)









